Brands consumer reports

Consumer Reports 2015 Memory Foam Mattress Rankings: Best and Worst Brands

On December 14, 2015 by Memory Foam Mattress Information

Unbiased product critiques could be very useful relating to making major shopping for selections, and Consumer Reports is among the most respected names in product scores. Annually, the organization collects and exams mattresses from in style manufacturers, providing readers an inside take a look at quality, sturdiness and worth.

On this report, we’ll be wanting specifically at Consumer Reports 2015 reminiscence foam mattress rankings, and seeing how they examine to other evaluate sources. We’ll also spotlight Consumer Reports’ mattress buying ideas, and add in a couple of reminiscence foam-specific ideas designed that will help you get the appropriate bed on your price range and wants.

Memory Foam Mattress Guide’s Prime Picks

Two of probably the most putting observations from the 2015 Consumer Reports mattress checks are that worth tells you probably little or no about comfort and sturdiness, and that shopper evaluations can even range quite a bit from the target rankings.

A number of the costliest and well-known manufacturers performed underwhelmingly, whereas a number of lesser recognized and reasonably priced beds did surprisingly properly. Nevertheless, Consumer Reports solely checks a very small portion of beds available on the market, leaving lots of of fashions and manufacturers out of the combination.

Based mostly on our personal research and comparisons of dozens of brands, listed here are the strains that earn one of the best mattress critiques and characterize one of the best general values when it comes to quality of materials, return insurance policies, and potential for long-term satisfaction.

MFMG’s Best Buys for Memory Foam Mattresses

MattressQueen WorthSpecsCritiquesAmerisleep Revere Bed$1499Med-firm
3” four.zero lb MF
9” foam core4.7 / 5
(400+ critiques, Amerisleep)BedInABox Silk Magnificence Gel Mattress$1449Med-firm
three” 3.zero lb Gel MF
8” foam core4.8 / 5
(51 evaluations, BedInABox)Lane Contura III Mattress$382Agency
2” 3 lb MF
10” artificial latex corefour.6 / 5
(450+ critiques, Walmart)

The mid-range Revere Mattress from Amerisleep earns a prime spot in our rankings, with overwhelmingly constructive shopper critiques. The Revere options medium density reminiscence foam, with a singular plant-based method that gives environmental benefits. Covers include a fiber referred to as Celliant, that absorbs body warmth and transforms into a useful infrared waves utilizing patented mineral fibers. Amerisleep can also be a longtime on-line retailer, with robust warranty and return policies.

Also within the center worth vary, the Silk Magnificence mattress from Mattress In A Box does properly in online critiques. Bed In A Box contains a signature type pairing decrease density gel memory foam with high-density poly foam cores, and tends to do properly on sturdiness. The Silk model options natural silk fibers within the cover that help moisture stability and breathability. Bed In A Box is a longtime retailer, and they too supply good return and warranty insurance policies.

Among the many finances reminiscence foam mattress strains, the Contura III by Lane (bought on Walmart’s website) provides one of many higher quality profiles in the beneath $500 vary. This mattress uses low-density reminiscence foam like most cheaper fashions, but moderately than using a poly foam core, it uses a synthetic latex core, which can supply a sturdiness and help advantage. It earns above common critiques, and has a comparatively good warranty and return coverage.

See How Our Picks In comparison with Consumer Reports 2015 Memory Foam Mattress Scores

The 2015 Consumer Reports mattress shopping for guide consists of each established manufacturers and newer corporations for each innerspring and foam beds. On this article, we’re wanting solely on the foam mattress manufacturers.

Extra specialty mattresses are included this yr than in previous years, which mirrors retail tendencies displaying speedy progress for memory foam and latex as more individuals search options to spring beds. Additionally they checked out more on-line retailers, a quickly rising sector especially for younger consumers.

The Consumer Reports guide groups all foam mattresses collectively (latex, memory foam, and poly foam). General, they recommend this class’s advantages are contouring and motion isolation, however the some individuals might find odor and warmth to be disadvantages.

This yr, they examined 16 foam mattresses from quite a lot of manufacturers and worth ranges. Among the many beds they examined, scores different significantly and confirmed a number of surprises, with some in style manufacturers failing to stay up to their premium costs. Full results are available only to paying subscribers, however press releases and news articles have provided some insight to the very best and lowest rated beds from the 2015 checks, compares under.

Best-Rated Memory Foam Mattresses: CR’s Prime 5

Within the table under, we’ve listed the 5 foam beds that earned the top scores from the group Consumer Reports examined in 2015. These beds are sorted from highest to lowest score, and we’ve also included third-party shopper assessment sources when out there, for comparison.

MattressQueen WorthSpecsCR ScoreCritiquesSerta iComfort Savant Everfeel$1,574Smooth
2” 3lb MF
2” foam
1.5” 4lb gel MF
6” foam core674.1 / 5
(Serta)Spring Air Again Supporter Natalie$1,099Medium
2.25” foam
⅜” gel MF
1” gel latex
7” foam core643.7 / 5
(Costco)Tuft & Needle The T&N Mattress$600Medium
3” 2.8lb foam
7” 1.8lb foam core64four.8 / 5
(Amazon)Casper The Casper Mattress$850Medium
1.5” dunlop latex
1.5” 4lb MF
6.5” foam core644.6 / 5
(Casper)Ikea Morgongava$999Medium
7.8” 85% pure latex mix
Wool padding
Cotton cover63NA

Among the prime scorers, the scores truly came in pretty shut to at least one another, ranging from 67 to 64 points on a 100 level scale (prime spring mattresses typically fee pretty equally). All the prime contenders are in the low to center worth vary.

One of the best-rated reminiscence foam bed was the Serta iComfort Savant Everfeel. This model earns good critiques in comparison with different iComfort beds, and generally, Serta tends to earn average to above average scores on shopper assessment websites. The Savant uses both low density and medium density memory foam layers which performed properly in checks, nevertheless it’s worth level of $1575 is considerably larger than the others within the prime five.

Three mattresses tied at scores of 64. The Spring Air Natalie and the Casper 10 mattresses each include layers of medium density reminiscence foam and latex atop foam cores. Though the Natalie is costlier, the Caspar exhibits considerably larger owner critiques on their web site versus the Natalie’s on Costco.com. The Tuft and Needle mattress, a prime competitor to Caspar, additionally rated the identical and is the most cost effective at $600, but this mattress is made only with poly foam layers (it accommodates no reminiscence foam or latex). Each Caspar and Tuft and Needle are pretty new to the market nevertheless, so long-term owner info is restricted.

Rounding out the top 5 with a score of 63, the IKEA Morgongava mattress is definitely an all-latex foam bed, priced moderately at slightly below $1000. There are very minimal third celebration IKEA mattress evaluations out there, but this mattress does seem to earn comparatively good feedback in the IKEA lineup, and it does supply a reasonably green buy with 85% natural materials.

Worst-Rated Memory Foam Mattresses: CR’s Bottom 5

The following desk lists the 5 foam beds that earned the bottom scores from the group Consumer Reports examined in 2015. These beds are sorted from highest to lowest score, and we’ve additionally included third-party shopper evaluation sources when out there, for comparison.

MattressQueen WorthSpecsCR ScoreCritiquesSpa Sensations 10” SPA-1000Q$315Medium
2.5” 3lb MF
2” foam
5.5” foam core574.6 / 5
(Walmart)Ikea Matrand$399Medium
Rayon padding
2” three.1 lb memory foam
5.1” 1.7 lb core foam57NASealy Posturepedic Optimum Inspiration$1,774Gentle
2” 4lb gel MF
three” 4lb gel MF
7” gel foam core522.3 / 5
(Amazon)Ara 13” 100% Visco Memory Foam$1,099Smooth
6-⅝” 5lb MF
6” foam core48four.2 / 5
(Costco)Tempurpedic Cloud Supreme$2,499Tender
1.2” 4.1lb MF
1.6” 5.3lb MF
eight” foam core324.zero / 5
(Tempurpedic)

The bottom rating beds from the 2015 Consumer Reports mattress exams included each low cost and costly beds.

Two cheap models rated at 57, the Spa Sensations 10″ and IKEA Matrand sell for beneath $400 and use low density memory foam. Though these mattresses didn’t truthful in addition to others within the exams, shopper evaluations do praise their good value — so while the lower-quality materials might have an effect on long-term sturdiness and satisfaction, these beds might still be respectable for short time period or visitor use.

The Ara, a mid-range Costco model, scored significantly lower the another Costco contender in the same vary. Surprisingly, the Ara makes use of a thick layer of high-density reminiscence foam and has good critiques, however the mannequin didn’t stand as much as it’s peers within the CR exams.

The two greater surprises of the 2015 checks have been the less-than-stellar performances from two luxury strains, Sealy Optimum and Tempurpedic.

Sealy’s Inspiration mattress acquired a score of 52, and critiques on third get together web sites also spotlight below-average efficiency on sturdiness and help. This mattress makes use of several inches of medium density memory foam, and is priced in the luxurious vary.

The Tempurpedic Cloud Supreme mattress earned the bottom score of each foam mattress tested, at solely 32, regardless of its excessive worth. This line uses a softer memory foam than others in the Tempur range, estimated to be in the medium density vary. While the Cloud Supreme didn’t rise up in CR exams, it does earn barely above common shopper evaluations on the model’s website and elsewhere.

Worth Breakdown of Consumer Reports Worst Rated mattresses

The above chart exhibits that the majority of worst mattresses rated by Consumer Reports have been over $1,000 dollars. This simply reinforces how the worth of a mattress doesn’t determine its quality.

Other mattresses examined however not talked about within the tables above all scored in the center, between 58 and 63 factors. These embrace the Comforpedic iQ180, Sleep Innovations 12″ Gel, Novaform Altabella, Ikea Myrbacka, Night time Remedy 14″ Deluxe Grand, iComfort Genius, and the iComfort Instructions Acumen.

How Consumer Reports Rates Mattresses and Why it Issues

Mattresses are maybe probably the most private gadgets a person buys, making score them fairly subjective. We all have unique concepts of comfort, based mostly on personal choice, weight, sleep position, health and rather more. There isn’t any singular definition of comfort, and the huge number of mattress varieties and manufacturers obtainable are testament to this variety.

Since there isn’t a approach to define comfort, Consumer Reports mattress testing process seems at the goal issues that can be measured, like sturdiness and firmness. Here’s an summary of the knowledge they acquire and examine:

[ul float=”none”][li icon=”icon-circle”]A roller check exhibits how nicely a mattress holds as much as repeated compression. A mattress that breaks down shortly will lose help and it’s capacity to cushion towards strain points, and in fact, poor sturdiness means worse general value because the mattress will must be changed sooner.[/li] [li icon=”icon-circle”]A gaggle of machines measures the curve of testers’ backs each standing and mendacity down, to find out how properly a mattress supports back and aspect sleepers. Help is the crucial perform of any mattress. Ideally, a bed should help pure alignment in your essential sleep place.[/li] [li icon=”icon-circle”]Strain maps gauge potential strain factors. Strain factors can lead to numbness and ache, which may mean extra tossing and turning through the night time and less snug sleep. Heavier areas like hips and shoulders and bonier areas like ankles/heels and elbows are most vulnerable to strain points.[/li] [li icon=”icon-circle”]A standardized indentation check measures actual firmness versus producer said firmness. An organization that’s inconsistent with their claims could make it troublesome to determine the perfect fit, notably for internet buyers.[/li]
[li icon=”icon-circle”]A bounce check determines how much motion switch a mattress yields. High motion switch can imply disturbed sleep, particularly for couples.[/li] [/ul]

So, estimated durability, help, strain, firmness and bounciness are the primary elements that Consumer Reports’ mattress scores are based mostly on. This knowledge supplies a primary and constant strategy to examine several types of beds, but be mindful it nonetheless can’t management for comfort and personal choice. Relating to memory foam particularly, some sources additionally recommend that these exams is probably not very correct, since they have been all designed for spring mattresses — another thing to think about as you examine.

Your personal sleep preferences, sleep habits, weight and body shape will all nonetheless play a big position in what you discover snug — just because a mattress charges nicely doesn’t imply you’ll get nice sleep on it, and vice versa. The important thing takeaways, nevertheless, could be quality compared to friends, and potential means to offer good help.

Consumer Reports’ Mattress Buying Ideas: Easy methods to Get The Best Deal

Consumer Reports presents a number of ideas for navigating the difficult mattress market based mostly on their research. Their newest model consists of the following options:

[ul float=”none”][li icon=”icon-circle”]Examine totally different mattress varieties, including memory foam, innersprings, and adjustable inflatable beds.[/li] [li icon=”icon-circle”]Avoid widespread myths. Thick foam layers, more coils, and lumbar layers are sometimes used to increase mattress prices and upsell shoppers, but testing exhibits that these extras don’t all the time make a mattress better.[/li] [li icon=”icon-circle”]Gel infused-foam didn’t make foam mattresses really feel cooler, particularly when the gel layers have been buried beneath different foams and supplies.[/li]
[li icon=”icon-circle”]Know that comparability purchasing claims might be faulty. Retailers can have a tough time figuring out comparable beds, particularly for manufacturers that don’t revealed detailed specification info.[/li] [li icon=”icon-circle”]Check a mattress earlier than buying if attainable, and don’t let sales individuals make you are feeling pressured for taking your time. However, Consumer Reports 2015 information also finds that a number of online retailers are doing nicely in critiques, and that buying from established ones is usually low-risk because of truthful return insurance policies. And, shopping for on-line also means less gross sales strain and extra competitive pricing.[/li] [li icon=”icon-circle”]Verify return and warranty policies before buying. Return info ought to embrace the time-frame it’s a must to return and what fees can be associated with returning the mattress in case you need to take action. Warranties should explain full protection versus prorated durations and exactly what is roofed.[/li] [li icon=”icon-circle”]Many retailers will negotiate on worth, and many can honor sale costs any time of the yr so it doesn’t harm to ask.[/li]
[li icon=”icon-circle”]In case your present foundation is the proper in your new bed and in fine condition, you then don’t have to spend additional on the matching one in the event you don’t need to (but make sure that it’s not required in the guarantee policy).[/li][/ul]

When you’re ready to start out purchasing for a mattress, we also advocate taking a look at our earlier guides on selecting the most effective mattress firmness and our detailed reminiscence foam shopping for information to study extra about comparing quality and features. Critiques, guides and sources like Consumer Reports mattress scores is usually a huge assist, as the more you recognize about reminiscence foam and the options on the market, the higher outfitted you’re to make a sensible selection.

Share: What do you think of Consumer Reports 2015 Mattress Scores — are they correct, or how do they examine together with your purchasing experiences?